sarasa_cat: (Default)
[personal profile] sarasa_cat
It is hard to explain my mixed feelings about MBTI ... I find it useful until I do not and there are so many ways in which it is not useful plus there is so much MBTI garbage littering the planet.

That said, something struck me earlier today -- The Anna Karenina Principle and how it applied (to some extent) to MBTI, and that became the seed for a 4500 word essay on Tumblr.


Date: Wednesday, 6 March 2019 01:26 am (UTC)
breakfastdragon: (Default)
From: [personal profile] breakfastdragon
Wow, long informative post is long and informative!

I was thinking while we were talking about the mistyping of INTJ-INFJ that my problems with mental illness are probably fouling up both my perception of my cognitive process AND my cognitive process itself. So it's not a huge surprise that I'm confused.

I'm intrigued by the concept of tertiary loops. I went and did some more research about the symptoms of tertiary loops for both INTJ and INFJ, and hoooly shit the INTJ Ni-Fi loop pretty much describes my experience, and why I might not be presenting as a stereotypical INTJ. Whereas the Ni-Ti loop doesn't register for me at all. And the fact that this tertiary loop rings so true to me is really interesting because it also lends itself to strategies that I can use to get out of it, some of which I hadn't thought about in this way before, by focusing on Te.

[Edited to add: And all of this stuff about the cognitive functions actually explains me-as-an-INTJ much more than the stereotypical, horoscope-like descriptions of INTJ, which I always found a complete turn off. The description of Fi as having a strong sense of internal values that you try to align your behaviour and lives to is not often included in generic INTJ descriptions.]

Really really interesting, thank you for typing it all up and sharing!

[Edited AGAIN to add: There's a lot of different things out there about Ni-Ti loops, and not all of them ring true to me (i.e. conspiracy theorist?). But this one had me:]
Edited Date: Wednesday, 6 March 2019 01:49 am (UTC)

Re: ...this is such a can of worms. Can. Of. Worms.

Date: Wednesday, 6 March 2019 02:17 am (UTC)
breakfastdragon: (Default)
From: [personal profile] breakfastdragon
I like your description of the tertiary and 4th functions as teenager and toddler respectively ;) It makes a lot of sense though, especially when considered in the context of their environment. I have started listening to some of the personality hacker podcast (specifically on the loops right now, because that is really speaking to me), and there is just so much to this theory. So many levels.

We used MBTI and the HBDI ( models when I was in the public service... mostly they were used as a way of learning more about yourself and the people you work with so that you can get along better, but I understand that sometimes they can be used to screen people in or out of certain professions, which is just all kinds of wrong.


sarasa_cat: (Default)

April 2019

78910 111213

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Wednesday, 24 April 2019 04:26 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios